Philip F. Lawler
Phil is the editor of
CWNews.com, which brings you daily news headlines from a Catholic perspective. He is the author of The Faithful Departed, a history of the Church in Boston and the scandal of the abuse of children by priests.

Tuesday, July 8, 2008

the silent treatment

The Albany Law School library has announced some new book purchases, and The Faithful Departed is on the list.

What's so remarkable about that? Nothing, really. I assume that many libraries have bought my book. But I'm beginning to wonder whether any Catholic schools would be willing to announce the purchase of this book-- which is, after all, about the contemporary problems of the Catholic Church.

This past weekend, a friend went to the desk at the bookstore of a major Catholic university and asked for The Faithful Departed. The bookstore manager was happy to provide a copy-- from under the counter; it wasn't on the shelves. The book wasn't actually wrapped in brown paper, but the message was clear nonetheless. My book is being sold on the sly, so that the bookstore won't catch flak from the clerical powers-that-be.

My friend's recent experience is not unique. In a different church-owned bookstore, in a different city, another friend asked for my book. The cheerful woman behind the counter said that she would be happy to order it. But hadn't it been on the display rack just a few days earlier, my friend inquired? Wouldn't the store order a new shipment, if they'd run out? The clerk smiled and repeated that she would be happy to order it, pointedly ignoring the questions. Notice that the clerk didn't ask my friend to repeat the title, nor did she need to consult her computer records to determine availability. She was evidently carrying out a policy that had been recently established in that store. There too my book had been pulled off the shelves, apparently as the result of a call from Someone Important.

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

According to WorldCat (an online union catalog of the collections and services of more than 10,000 libraries worldwide) the following libraries or library consortia (representing a group of libraries) have The Faithful Departed:

AKRON-SUMMIT CNTY PUB LIBR
ALBANY LAW SCH
ALLEN CNTY PUB LIBR
ALLENTOWN PUB LIBR
ATHENAEUM OF OHIO
BAYLOR UNIV
BEAUFORT CNTY PUB LIBR US,MA BENTLEY COL
BETHLEHEM AREA PUB LIBR
BOB JONES UNIV LIBR
BOSTON COL
BOSTON PUB LIBR
BRISTOL COMMUN COL
BROWN UNIV
C/W MARS
CATHOLIC UNIV OF AMERICA
CHICAGO PUB LIBR
CLAMS, INC
CUMBERLAND CNTY LIBR SYST
DAYTON METROP LIBR
DENVER PUB LIBR
DIVINE WORD COL, MATTHEW JACOBY LIBR
DUQUESNE UNIV LIBR
EMORY UNIV, PITTS THEOL LIBR T
ENFIELD PUB LIBR
EUGENE PUB LIBR
FAIRFIELD PUB LIBR
FALMOUTH PUB LIBR
FLORIDA STATE UNIV
FORDHAM UNIV
FRAMINGHAM STATE COL
GAIL BORDEN PUB LIBR DIST
GEORGETOWN UNIV
GREENWICH LIBR
HARTFORD SEMINARY
HARVARD UNIV, HARVARD COL LIBR
HELEN M PLUM MEM LIBR
HIGH PLAINS LIBR DIST
INDIANA UNIV
INDIANA UNIV, PURDUE UNIV, INDIANAPOLIS
INDIANAPOLIS-MARION CNTY PUB LIBR
IONA COL
JOINT FREE PUB LIBR, MORRISTOWN/TOWNSHIP
KENRICK-GLENN SEMINARY LIBR
KING CNTY LIBR SYST
KOOTENAI-SHOSHONE AREA LIBRARIES
LIBRARY OF CONGRESS
LOS ANGELES PUB LIBR
LOUISVILLE PRESBYTERIAN THEOL SEMINARY
LOYOLA UNIV
LOYOLA UNIV OF CHICAGO
LUTHER SEMINARY LIBR
MARQUETTE UNIV RAYNOR MEMORIAL LIBR
MARSHFIELD PUB LIBR
MCGILL UNIV
MERCYHURST COL HAMMERMILL LIBR
MERRIMACK VAL LIBR CONSOR
MIAMI UNIV
MIAMI-DADE PUB LIBR SYST
MID-CONTINENT PUB LIBR
MILWAUKEE CNTY FEDERATED LIBR SYST
MINUTEMAN LIBR NETWORK
MONTEREY PUB LIBR
MOUNT ANGEL ABBEY LIBR
NASSAU LIBR SYST
NEUMANN COL LIBR
NEW HAMPSHIRE STATE LIBR PROC CTR
NOBLE, INC
OAK PARK PUB LIBR
OBLATE SCH OF THEOL
OCEAN CNTY LIBR
OCEAN STATE LIBR
OLD COLONY LIBR NETWORK
OUR LADY OF GUADALUPE SEMINARY
PONTIFICAL COL JOSEPHINUM
POPE JOHN XXIII NAT SEMINARY LIBR
PRINCE GEORGE'S CNTY MEM LIBR SYST
PRINCETON THEOLOGICAL SEMINARY
PRINCETON UNIV PUL
PROVIDENCE COL, PHILLIPS MEM LIBR
PURDUE UNIV
RAHWAY PUB LIBR
REGIS UNIV COR
SAILS, INC
SAINT ANSELM COL
SAINT BONAVENTURE UNIV
SAINT CHARLES BORROMEO SEM, OVERBROOK
SAINT FRANCIS SEMINARY, SALZMANN LIBR
SAINT JOHN VIANNEY SEMINARY, DENVER
SAINT JOSEPH'S COL LIBR
SAINT JOSEPH'S SEMINARY
SAINT LOUIS CNTY LIBR
SAINT MEINRAD ARCHABBEY & SCH OF THEOL
SAN DIEGO STATE UNIV LIBR
SEATTLE PUB LIBR
SIOUX CITY PUB LIBR
SOUTHERN METHODIST UNIV, BRIDWELL LIBR
SPOKANE CNTY LIBR DIST
ST MARY SEMINARY OHIO
TEXAS CHRISTIAN UNIV
TULANE UNIV
UNIV OF ALABAMA
UNIV OF ALBERTA
UNIV OF BALTIMORE
UNIV OF CALIFORNIA, IRVINE
UNIV OF COLORADO AT BOULDER
UNIV OF DELAWARE
UNIV OF GEORGIA
UNIV OF ILLINOIS, CHICAGO
UNIV OF IOWA LIBR
UNIV OF MARYLAND, COL PARK
UNIV OF MIAMI
UNIV OF MISSOURI, KANSAS CITY
UNIV OF MISSOURI, ST LOUIS
UNIV OF N CAROLINA, CHAPEL HILL
UNIV OF NOTRE DAME
UNIV OF PENNSYLVANIA
UNIV OF ST THOMAS
UNIV OF TEXAS AT AUSTIN
UNIV OF VERMONT, BAILEY LIBR
UNIV OF VIRGINIA
VANDERBILT UNIV LIBR
VASSAR COL
WALLA WALLA UNIV
WELLES-TURNER MEM LIBR
WEST LAFAYETTE PUB LIBR
WESTERN MICHIGAN UNIV
WESTON JESUIT SCH OF THEOL
WHEATON COL

M. Alexander said...

Impressive list.

Gabriel Austin said...

It does no good to complain without names.